Skip to main content

Defining Constitutionally protected Firearms

In D.C. vs. Heller the court gave gun owners the gift of vague descriptions of firearms that are protected and therefore cannot be banned.

The Court avoided defining constitutionally protected weapons other than to say that, it protects handguns and other weapons "in common use." The court suggested that dangerous or unusual weapons may not be protected and sidestepped saying just what those were.

Weapons in common use applies to military and police weapons. That makes the case that the banned black semi-automatic rifles and pistols with large capacity magazines that are, in common use cannot be denied.

This has gotten interesting, because USA vs. Miller held military type weapons are protected. Now Heller says that gun possession is an individual right rather than a government or collective right.

I can only see one meaning here and that is a much broader assortment of weapons are now definitively protected including all semi-automatic and perhaps fully automatic weapons.

I take this to mean that neither states nor the federal government can ban the ownership of National Firearms Act weapons. Before you could only own these in states that allowed these registered class III weapons.

The bans on .50 caliber rifles and the high capacity, “black guns” can no longer stand.

We will wait as nearly every criminal defendant charged with various gun law violations and their lawyers wait for a turn at the Wheel of Justice. The slower civil cases brought by the NRA and Second Amendment Foundation may be moot by the time they are heard.

The bad news here that people are rarely arrested for simple possession of banned weapons. Those arrested are usually charged with assault, or a smorgasbord of other offenses. It will be gun collectors or others caught with these weapons by chance that will be testing the various gun bans in court.

California, New Jersey, New York and a few other places are going to see their penal codes shrink as these now invalid laws cease to exist.

I hope to hear from a few legal beagles on this posting.

Comments

TheBronze said…
Paul, in my heart, I pray you're right. But in my gut, I know you're wrong.

That's a beer I'd love to buy you.

We'll see...
Anonymous said…
They arent getting my Barrett M82a1!!

From my cold dead hands!!!!!!!!!!!!
Anonymous said…
Paul,the real intent of the Second Amendment is never discussed.The NRA and every other pro-gun group play the PC game too.

The 2nd Amend. isnt about gun collecting,duck hunting,self-defense or target shooting.

The founding fathers wanted to make sure its populace was properly armed to remove a tyrannical government,PERIOD.

The 1st Amend. was put in place as peaceful methods to pressure those bent on evil.N0.2 gives you the teeth No.1 the bark.
Anonymous said…
Miller basically affirmed our god givin right to own any small arm suitable for military/police use.

You cant believe the amount of CPD f*&ktards that think machineguns-silencers-short barreled shotguns are illegal.

They oviously missed that in detective school and never covered what a form 1 or 4 is.
Anonymous said…
Let’s hope those Chinese bastards invade and give us their way of life. Our current politicians would welcome them like long lost friends

July 20, 2008 8:50 PM

Careful what you wish for.The Wal-Mart supply house is building a nuclear powered aircraft carrier and a ballistic missile sub.Both of these are used for projecting foriegn policy,thats what we do with ours.
I agree that the court never got the Second Amendment right. It was intended that whatever weapons the government had we could keep and carry.

The problem is those nine Justices get the last word and they have spoken. They gave us what we got and it could have been a whole lot worse. I doubt we will get anymore from the court I our lifetime. We need to protect what we have.

Let’s hope those Chinese bastards don’t invade and give us their way of life. Our current politicians would welcome them like long lost friends and help them collect our firearms with the UN troops.
Anonymous said…
What most people do not realize is that I can own a M4 Sherman tank with a live 75mm main gun.I can also put in the M37 .30 MGs and a M2 .50 up top too.
Anonymous said…
Paul,use this one on the idiot crowd when they talk about how deadly guns are.Right now it would cost about $4.24 ymmv.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Land_fire

Popular posts from this blog

A 40 Caliber Nightmare Is Caught On Tape.

So you’re confident that that .40 caliber S&W service round will keep you safe. Maybe you’ll have second thoughts after you see this video. One hot summer night in 1994 Tempe and Mesa Arizona police were involved in a pursuit with this suspect who ran into a stranger’s apartment to hide after being shot TWICE in the chest. He was shirtless and you can see the blood pumping out of those two wounds. What’s really frightening is just how agile this fellow is as he struts to the ambulance. If he was not handcuffed and had a knife or a gun, ask yourself if he could still hurt you, your partner or a hostage? If your jurisdiction demands that officers carry either the 9MM or the .40 Caliber S&W it’s time to show this video to your bosses and lobby to have the .45 ACP round authorized. The switch may well reduce the screaming by self-appointed community activists about how many rounds police had to use on a suspect. The really talented and courageous video journalist, Karen Ke...

America Will See Its Worst Race Riot Yet This Summer

Star Prosecution Witness, Rachel Jeantel Sanford, FL —Yes, the George Zimmerman trial here has thousands of African-Americans getting ready for some serious bloodletting. I don’t want to make idle and dire predictions but this nation has never been so divided and racially sensitive.  Our African-American President took sides on this case at the very beginning.  That ratified a George Zimmerman guilty verdict in the minds of millions. There’s just one little problem, and that is the murder case should have never been filed.  It was filed purely for political reasons despite the fact that it was a simple justifiable homicide.  Zimmerman was on the block watch lookout program and followed a suspicious Trayvon Martin after he used an improper entrance to a gated community.  Zimmerman was acting as the eyes and ears of the Sanford Police Department. Martin did not like being followed and knew that he could easily beat up the out-of-shape...

The origin of the feature film, COME FRIDAY…

CLick On the pictures to see full size versions. Long ago there was a young lady I had the hots for in a big way (Yes, I know that hots is not a word). She was pretty, incredibly bright, and had some real elegance about her. She had a love for children and basic kindness that you don’t often see in someone her age. I met her parents and could understand she came from a much more stable home than mine. I was raised by a single, welfare mom and suddenly found myself way out-classed. For whatever reasons things did not workout they way I had hoped. Sadly for me, we went on our separate ways. From time to time I’d run into this lady in various places where our job had taken us. Whenever this happened my heart would skip a beat or two. I left my hometown Chicago, and moved to Arizona where I founded my detective agency. As a private eye and soon a TV news producer too, my career took me to the highest profile criminal events in Arizona and throughout the country. There’s no question that ...