Skip to main content

Murder Charges Dismissed Against Scottsdale Lawyer David Appleton

Phoenix, AZ—David Appleton has had a very rough and expensive week. Last Thursday night the 59 year-old lawyer was chased down Pima Road by an angry driver who cornered him behind a drug store, jumped out of his vehicle and attempted to strangle him. Appleton apparently produced a .38 revolver in an effort to halt the attack. When the sight of the gun had no effect on his younger assailant a single shot ended the life of an angry, Paul “Tom” Pearson.

Scottsdale police refused to believe Appleton’s claims of self-defense and arrested him on murder charges. The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office reviewed the known facts and physical evidence and found there was insufficient evidence to support the charges. Prosecutors motioned the court this morning to dismiss the direct complaint.

Should the Scottsdale police find enough evidence for probable cause they may bring it forward to prosecutors for prosecution. For now Dave Appleton is free.

Everyone in the defense side of this case including David Appleton recognize the sorrow that Pearson’s wife and three daughters are going through right now. I think it’s fair to say that Pearson had a good side that his family and friends will miss. I hope that his family is able to move on and experience success and love that Pearson surely would have wanted for them.

There is a lesson to learn here and that’s to try and ignore those drivers that irritate all of us. Arizona gives motorists the same protection and people have in their homes. Deadly force can be used to prevent crimes and assaults in cars as well as homes. Conflict avoidance is always the best policy.

Labels:

Comments

Anonymous said…
Congrats to David. The same thing happened to me 4 years ago, in an FJ Cruiser, on Pinnacle Peak, at night, by a druggy that had a .19 BAC, who choked me. But I am not an attorney. The same day Appleton was released, my jury was hung after 2 months of trial. I gues I should have gone to law school.
November 18, 2011 5:22 PM
Anonymous said…
It's worthy to note that were it not for the professional private investigation that you Paul afforded Mr. Appleton, that he may very well have had to go through a most expensive trail - he should kiss your tush in Macy's window to say the least! As for your kind remarks for the deceased family, all well and good BUT, lets not lose sight of the fact that it was Pearson who got out of his vehicle and choked Mr. Appleton and who placed him in far of death so much so that Appleton shot him to save his own life in self defense. Well done Paul!
November 18, 2011 6:02 PM
Paul Huebl Crimefile News said…
I'm proud to specialize in deadly force, self defense cases. My clients compensate me well and I give them all I can accordingly.

I knew there were things the Scottsdale police did not know or overlooked. I was blessed by being called in early enough to uncover information in time to make a difference.

Nobody, especially David Appleton wants to take a human life. Though justifiable and necessary this even will forever change this senior lawyer's life.
November 18, 2011 6:21 PM
Anonymous said…
Good Job Paul!!!
November 18, 2011 8:56 PM
Anonymous said…
Great result Paul. Also, you are very gracious to consider the innocent victims of this tragic incident.
November 19, 2011 7:42 PM
32.and.Stewart said…
Great job Paul. You really followed this one from the beginning and were very informative.
Great blog!

Former CPD.....
November 22, 2011 2:44 PM
Anonymous said…
Bill Montgomery is doing the right thing because it is the government that must prove that Appleton broke the law, not the other way around.

The evidence is clear that it was Pearson that chased and assaulted Appleton. All bullies deserve what Pearson got, lead poisoning!
November 25, 2011 12:34 AM
Anonymous said…
Tell Appleton to sue for false arrest.
December 20, 2011 12:19 AM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A 40 Caliber Nightmare Is Caught On Tape.

So you’re confident that that .40 caliber S&W service round will keep you safe. Maybe you’ll have second thoughts after you see this video. One hot summer night in 1994 Tempe and Mesa Arizona police were involved in a pursuit with this suspect who ran into a stranger’s apartment to hide after being shot TWICE in the chest. He was shirtless and you can see the blood pumping out of those two wounds. What’s really frightening is just how agile this fellow is as he struts to the ambulance. If he was not handcuffed and had a knife or a gun, ask yourself if he could still hurt you, your partner or a hostage? If your jurisdiction demands that officers carry either the 9MM or the .40 Caliber S&W it’s time to show this video to your bosses and lobby to have the .45 ACP round authorized. The switch may well reduce the screaming by self-appointed community activists about how many rounds police had to use on a suspect. The really talented and courageous video journalist, Karen Ke...
64 comments
Read more

America Will See Its Worst Race Riot Yet This Summer

Star Prosecution Witness, Rachel Jeantel Sanford, FL —Yes, the George Zimmerman trial here has thousands of African-Americans getting ready for some serious bloodletting. I don’t want to make idle and dire predictions but this nation has never been so divided and racially sensitive.  Our African-American President took sides on this case at the very beginning.  That ratified a George Zimmerman guilty verdict in the minds of millions. There’s just one little problem, and that is the murder case should have never been filed.  It was filed purely for political reasons despite the fact that it was a simple justifiable homicide.  Zimmerman was on the block watch lookout program and followed a suspicious Trayvon Martin after he used an improper entrance to a gated community.  Zimmerman was acting as the eyes and ears of the Sanford Police Department. Martin did not like being followed and knew that he could easily beat up the out-of-shape...
80 comments
Read more

The origin of the feature film, COME FRIDAY…

CLick On the pictures to see full size versions. Long ago there was a young lady I had the hots for in a big way (Yes, I know that hots is not a word). She was pretty, incredibly bright, and had some real elegance about her. She had a love for children and basic kindness that you don’t often see in someone her age. I met her parents and could understand she came from a much more stable home than mine. I was raised by a single, welfare mom and suddenly found myself way out-classed. For whatever reasons things did not workout they way I had hoped. Sadly for me, we went on our separate ways. From time to time I’d run into this lady in various places where our job had taken us. Whenever this happened my heart would skip a beat or two. I left my hometown Chicago, and moved to Arizona where I founded my detective agency. As a private eye and soon a TV news producer too, my career took me to the highest profile criminal events in Arizona and throughout the country. There’s no question that ...
42 comments
Read more