From Edward R. Murrow to Restaurant Openings, Police Helicopters, and Journalistic Idiocy
By Paul Huebl
Local television news has become an absolute nightmare. What was once a respected profession dedicated to informing the public has deteriorated into an embarrassing carnival of superficial nonsense, mindless chatter, and journalism so shallow that a mosquito could wade through it without getting its knees wet.
There was a time when Americans turned on their televisions because they actually wanted to know what the hell was happening in the world. Edward R. Murrow brought us serious journalism. Walter Cronkite continued that tradition with intelligence, credibility, and an understanding that the news was supposed to INFORM people, not entertain them like a bunch of toddlers at a birthday party.
Today? You're lucky to get three minutes of meaningful news sandwiched between restaurant openings, celebrity gossip, adorable puppies, and some grinning idiot telling us where to buy the best goddamn cupcakes. Apparently, the greatest threat facing civilization is a shortage of trendy taco restaurants.
Of course, I'm not invited to those mysterious television focus groups where consultants, executives, and assorted geniuses supposedly determine what viewers want. I can only imagine the intellectual firepower assembled in those rooms. “Should we investigate government corruption, violent crime, and public safety failures?” “Hell no! Let's send somebody to interview a chef about his new avocado toast!” And so another brilliant editorial decision is born.
REPORTING WITHOUT ACTUALLY REPORTING
Local television news stories have become exercises in how little information can be delivered while pretending to tell a complete story. A murder occurs. A suspect is arrested. A reporter stands in front of a building, solemnly informs us that police are investigating, and then announces that the investigation is ongoing. Well, thank God we cleared that up!
Who is the suspect? What's his background? Does he have a criminal record? Was he on probation or parole? Did he know the victim? What evidence exists? What might explain the crime? Those are apparently unreasonable questions to ask somebody whose job title is REPORTER.
Instead, we get the bare minimum, followed by the immortal words, “We'll bring you more information as it becomes available.” Translation: “We haven't bothered to find out anything else, and frankly, we're hoping somebody will email us a press release.”
Whatever happened to the old-fashioned field producers? Those magnificent bastards actually worked the neighborhoods. They knocked on doors, tracked down witnesses, interviewed neighbors, located surveillance cameras, and dug up information that police departments weren't particularly anxious to volunteer. They understood that journalism required getting off your ass and finding out what happened.
Today's reporters too often seem content to stand around waiting for their next live shot, occasionally adjusting their hair while the photographer checks the lighting. The live shot has become more important than the story itself. And God forbid somebody asks a question that might embarrass a mayor, police chief, district attorney, or other local political royalty.
Public officials have every reason to prefer flattering coverage over stories exposing their failures. That's precisely why journalists are supposed to challenge them, not function as unpaid members of their public relations departments. When television news becomes too cozy with City Hall, the public gets cheated.
THE CITIZEN APP: A GREAT IDEA IN SEARCH OF SOMEBODY WHO KNOWS WHAT HE'S DOING
One interesting alternative is the Citizen app. The concept has enormous potential. Monitor emergency activity, alert people to developing incidents, and encourage ordinary citizens with smartphones to provide video from the scene. In many situations, these people can reach an incident long before a television news crew ever arrives.
They have the cameras. They have the technology. They have immediate access. What they frequently don't have is the slightest idea how to report what they're witnessing.
I've watched these amateur broadcasters point their phones at police helicopters circling overhead while something important is happening right in front of them. Yes, congratulations! You've discovered a helicopter! It's flying! In the sky! Absolutely breathtaking! Now would you mind pointing that expensive little camera toward the actual emergency?
We can hear the helicopter. We can see that there's a helicopter. We don't need a fifteen-minute documentary establishing that helicopters are capable of remaining airborne. What we need to know is WHAT THE HELL IS HAPPENING ON THE GROUND!
Who saw the incident? What happened before the police arrived? Are there witnesses willing to speak? Did anyone see a suspect flee? What did the responding officers actually do? Here's a revolutionary suggestion: ASK SOMEBODY!
These citizen broadcasters often have an enormous advantage over professional television crews because they arrive early enough to encounter witnesses before everyone disappears. Yet that opportunity is frequently squandered.
I understand that these people aren't trained journalists. Nobody expects them to be Edward R. Murrow with an iPhone. But surely it doesn't require a graduate degree from Columbia University to ask a witness, “What did you see?” And if you don't know something, say so. Don't invent facts, speculate wildly, or repeat neighborhood gossip as established truth.
Here's another revolutionary idea: Why doesn't Citizen produce a series of short instructional videos teaching its amateur reporters the fundamentals of journalism? It wouldn't require a multimillion-dollar training academy or a faculty of Pulitzer Prize winners. A handful of practical videos could demonstrate how to interview witnesses, ask intelligent follow-up questions, photograph a developing incident, distinguish firsthand observations from rumors, and provide useful descriptions of people, vehicles, and events.
Teach them how to establish a timeline, identify potential witnesses, verify basic information, and avoid interfering with police, firefighters, or emergency medical personnel. Explain the importance of personal safety, respecting privacy, and recognizing the difference between what somebody actually witnessed and what somebody merely heard from a neighbor's cousin.
Hell, give these people a ten-minute lesson on keeping the camera pointed at the news instead of the clouds! Citizen could even recruit experienced retired reporters, photographers, and field producers to develop the material. There are plenty of seasoned news veterans who could teach more practical journalism in fifteen minutes than some aspiring broadcasters seem to learn in four years of college.
The cost would be relatively modest, and the potential improvement could be enormous. Better-trained citizen reporters could provide more useful information, more meaningful video, and a far better understanding of developing emergencies. Citizen already has the technology and the participants. Why not give them some basic skills to go along with their smartphones?
Citizen journalism could be a tremendous resource. Instead, too much of it resembles somebody accidentally activating a camera while wandering around a crime scene. A little training could make an enormous difference.
INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM: REST IN PEACE
Then there's investigative journalism. Remember that? It was the quaint practice of digging through records, cultivating sources, exposing corruption, confronting dishonest officials, and occasionally making powerful people so uncomfortable that they wished they'd chosen another profession.
Investigative reporting still exists, and some excellent journalists continue doing it. But in far too many local television markets, it seems to have become an endangered species. Investigations take time. They require money, experience, persistence, and news directors with enough backbone to withstand pressure from advertisers, politicians, and corporate executives.
Why spend three weeks exposing government incompetence when you can fill the same airtime with a woman demonstrating how to make a Thanksgiving centerpiece out of pinecones?
And where are the demanding news directors? There was a time when a reporter who returned from a major crime scene without meaningful information could expect a rather unpleasant conversation with the boss. Today, it sometimes seems that showing up, holding a microphone, and speaking in complete sentences is enough to qualify as outstanding journalism.
The result is an increasingly troubling shortage of reporters who know how to investigate, challenge official accounts, develop sources, or ask the next logical question. Some of these same reporters eventually graduate to national television. Wonderful! Now the entire country gets to enjoy their inability to ask a decent follow-up question.
CNN: FROM TED TURNER'S REVOLUTION TO THE TELEVISION SEWER
And then there's CNN. When Ted Turner launched CNN in 1980, he revolutionized television journalism. Imagine the audacity of the idea: NEWS, twenty-four hours a day! Not cooking demonstrations. Not endless panel discussions featuring professional loudmouths. Not manufactured outrage over the latest idiotic controversy. Actual news.
Turner's CNN became a remarkable international news organization. Its coverage of major world events demonstrated what around-the-clock television journalism could accomplish. It wasn't perfect, but it had ambition, purpose, and an unmistakable commitment to covering events as they unfolded.
Then Turner eventually departed the scene, corporate priorities changed, and in my opinion CNN began its long, humiliating slide down the proverbial shit chute. What a spectacle. A network that once helped define modern television journalism increasingly embraced the very disease that has infected so much of the industry: endless commentary, theatrical confrontation, repetitive speculation, and personalities who sometimes appear more interested in becoming celebrities than reporting the news.
Why send somebody out to discover new facts when you can assemble six people around a table to argue about the same three facts for the next four hours? That's not journalism. That's a televised bar fight without the beer.
THE REAL VICTIM IS THE PUBLIC
Perhaps the most depressing aspect of this entire mess is that I don't see much reason for optimism. Experienced reporters cost money. Investigations cost money. Field producers cost money. Quality journalism requires resources, training, and management willing to demand excellence.
Meanwhile, many news organizations face economic pressure, shrinking audiences, and the temptation to substitute inexpensive filler for expensive reporting. And when experienced journalists disappear, their institutional knowledge often disappears with them.
You cannot replace decades of investigative experience with a smartphone, a cheerful personality, and a communications degree. Nor can you turn a press release into journalism simply by having somebody read it while standing in front of City Hall.
The public deserves to know who's committing crimes, who's failing to prevent them, where taxpayer money is going, what public officials are concealing, and how government decisions affect their lives. We deserve reporters who investigate rather than merely repeat official statements. We deserve news directors who demand answers rather than attractive live shots. We deserve journalists who understand that the most important question is often the one somebody in authority desperately hopes nobody will ask.
Most of all, we deserve news organizations that respect the intelligence of their audiences.
Edward R. Murrow confronted powerful institutions. Walter Cronkite helped Americans understand historic events. Today's local television news might interrupt its cupcake coverage long enough to tell us that somebody was murdered, police are investigating, and further details are unavailable.
Then it's back to the studio, where two smiling anchors exchange witty remarks about the weather. And somewhere, I imagine, Edward R. Murrow is spinning in his grave so fast he could power a television transmitter.
Good night, and good luck. God knows television journalism needs both.

Comments