When I was a young policeman, cops carried revolvers. We did not have ballistic vests. We did not have high-capacity magazines hanging off our belts like Christmas ornaments. We had six rounds, training, nerve, and the serious expectation that every shot had better matter.
The gun battle statistics in those days were clear. Most gunfights were over after two or three shots.
Today, you walk into the aftermath of a shooting and the ground looks like somebody dumped a bucket of brass casings across the pavement. Shell casings everywhere. Rounds fired in every direction. A lot of noise, a lot of smoke, and sometimes very little evidence of actual marksmanship.
It looks painfully obvious that we have moved from marksmanship to panic. From aimed fire to spray and pray. From controlled violence to ammunition being launched into Nowhereville with great enthusiasm and questionable results.
Forgive me if I am not standing in absolute awe of today’s 9mm ammunition. Yes, modern 9mm ammunition is better than it used to be. No serious person should deny that. But let’s not pretend it has become magic. Too many people have been sold the fantasy that the handgun in their possession is an all-powerful man-stopper. That is television nonsense dressed up as training.
Even worse, many men seem unable to handle minimal recoil and act as if a .45 ACP is some kind of artillery piece. Women have also been led to believe they cannot handle meaningful recoil, as if physics suddenly changes because of gender. That kind of thinking does them no favors. It lowers expectations, and in a life-and-death encounter, lowered expectations can get people killed.
Police revolvers in .357 Magnum are not especially difficult to handle with proper instruction and practice. The San Francisco Police Department once issued Smith & Wesson Model 57 revolvers in .41 Magnum to its all-male patrol officers. They expected their officers to train, shoot well, and not arrive with a wagon full of excuses for poor marksmanship. When women were later hired into patrol positions, those Model 57s disappeared quickly. Draw your own conclusions, but do not pretend that recoil management is some impossible mystery reserved for superheroes and circus strongmen.
I am firmly of the opinion that when a person has a six-shot revolver instead of a semi-automatic pistol with a stacked magazine, he tends to become more disciplined. He is more likely to remember his training. He is more likely to understand that ammunition is not confetti. He is more likely to place his rounds with care instead of dumping bullets into the landscape and hoping one of them develops a conscience.
Now there is a real renaissance in revolver popularity, and there is a good reason for it. A proper revolver with the right grip simply feels right in the hand. With a quality aftermarket grip, such as the excellent offerings from eaglegrips.com, a revolver can feel less like a tool and more like a trusted extension of the shooter. Frankly, many factory grips seem to be installed only because the gun can’t be sold without something attached to the frame. Gun makers know their customers are probably going to replace them anyway, so why bother making them beautiful or comfortable? That seems to be the grand manufacturing philosophy.
A good revolver builds confidence. Not arrogance. Confidence. There is a difference, and it matters. When you hold a solid revolver that fits your hand correctly, you feel the seriousness of the weapon. You understand its limits. You understand your responsibility. You understand that every round must be accounted for.
That does not mean I am throwing cold water on semi-automatic pistols. I am not. A good semi-automatic in a serious caliber has a legitimate place. But trainers must pound one lesson into every student’s head: spraying and praying is rarely helpful. It is not strategy. It is not courage. It is not skill. It is panic with a trigger finger.
I do not care what gun you are using. Revolver, semi-automatic, 9mm, .45 ACP, .357 Magnum, or anything else. The prerequisite is competent instruction from a qualified firearms instructor. Not your father. Not your uncle. Not some loudmouth at the range who owns three holsters and suddenly thinks he is Jeff Cooper reincarnated.
The student must become almost obsessive about training. Safety. Grip. Stance. Sight alignment. Trigger control. Reloading. Malfunction drills. Movement. Cover. Judgment. Shot placement. Everything matters because this training is not designed to win trophies. It is designed to save lives.
I have seen too many cops show up for requalification and perform in a way that can only be called shameful. That is not a small problem. We all hate the idea of seeing fellow officers dead, but when officers are killed in gunfights, there is usually a failure somewhere. Sometimes it is bad tactics. Sometimes it is poor training. Sometimes it is arrogance. Sometimes it is hesitation. Sometimes it is simply a failure to apply what they were taught.
The issue is not how many shots you fire. The issue is whether you can place effective shots under extreme stress when somebody is trying to kill you.
Too many officers, and too many armed citizens, forget that most gun battles are very close affairs. You may not be shooting across a parking lot like some Hollywood action hero. You may be fighting at conversational distance, where everything is fast, violent, ugly, and final. At that distance, your job is not to make noise. Your job is to stop the threat.
That means shot placement. It means doing your best to put rounds where they can actually shut down the attacker’s motor functions. Not wound him. Not irritate him. Not rely on blood loss while he still has enough adrenaline left to kill you before he collapses.
Never forget this brutal truth: most people shot with firearms are only wounded. Many do not instantly fall down. Many do not even realize how badly they have been hit. Adrenaline can keep a violent attacker functioning after four or even 10 rounds, and during those final seconds, he may still have enough strength, rage, and purpose to kill you.
That is why training matters. That is why marksmanship matters. That is why discipline matters.
And that is why the old six-shot revolver still deserves respect. It forces the shooter to think. It forces accountability. It punishes sloppiness. It does not encourage the fantasy that more ammunition is a substitute for skill.
Whether you carry a revolver or a semi-automatic, the truth remains the same: the gun will not save you by itself. Your training, your judgment, your discipline, and your ability to place effective shots under pressure are what may save your life.
Everything else is just noise and brass on the ground.
Comments